School Research Centers & Public Service Units School Clinical & Diagnostic Services Units SVM Office of Research Programs Internal Web Site for Faculty, Staff, and Students Search SVM web sites Continuing Education Opportunities for Veterinarians How to Support the School SVM Research & Service Units Veterinary Medical Teaching Hospital Information and Resources for Prospective Students Teaching Programs at the School of Veterinary Medicine Administrative and Organizational Information about the School Learn About New Developments at the School Return to the School of Veterinary Medicine Home Page

Unobtrusive field methods for the study of wild animals:
database search strategies

Kenneth L Firestein, University of California, Davis, Carlson Health Sciences Library
Lynette A. Hart, University of California Center for Animal Alternatives



 
    Table of Contents:

Introduction

The objective of the information herein is to help with the search for publications about field methods for studying animals in the wild so as to have minimal impact on those animals. The immediate goals are to show how to find good citations to articles and books which contain information related to that objective and to show some results of such searches.

We want to know what research has been published on these topics. Two questions need to be answered to identify the publications:  (1) What words (keywords) in titles or abstracts or subject headings alert us that a publication is of interest to us? and (2) What databases have listed the publications and described them with subject headings and abstracts, etc? Then, after the publications are identified, we need to locate them in libraries and other such repositories.

The PubMed Database is often  the database first searched, we find, however, that the Biosis Database and the CAB International Databases give us better results; the list of  "Subject headings and keywords to use in searches" offers suggested keywords for obtaining the best results from that database. The section on Search Templates  gives examples from PubMed and Agricola because those two databases may be searched at no cost and they are set up so that real-time searches can be done from this page to get up-to-date results. Use The basic search strategy on creating a search strategy to do searches in Biosis and CAB when you have access to them. 


Back to the Top 
 



Where are books and journals located?

University of California, Davis  has a comprehensive list of electronic databases. We also provide a collection of databases in our Databases and Websites page.

The California Digital Library System from the University of California has two databases which are universally accessible and which provide useful location information.

Here is a good list of libraries throughout the world where you may locate books and journals near where you work. Most libraries will allow you to search their holdings, as libraries and librarians have a philosophically strong mission to freely share their resources.


Back to the Top





The basic search strategy

Be specific at first but not limiting.
If necessary, consider alternative approaches to your concerns and issues.
1. Determine the question you are asking. How can field studies of wild animals be conducted unobtrusively?
2. Choose the databases related to your question and needs. This example uses the PubMed Database and does not produce good results. Results from other databases of this and other searches will be shown below.
3. List and organize keywords from your question. "Organization" of the keywords means how they will be used with the boolean operators AND and OR, and also with ADJACENCY operators, where available. 
4. Keywords may be "authoritative" and may be different in different databases. In PubMed you may mix subject terms from the "authoritative" Medical Subject Headings List (MeSH) with keywords which will be from the titles and abstracts (non-authoritative).

COMBINING/Crossing of terms means to cause the computers to produce a list of citations to journal articles or books which meet certain search criteria. The boolean OR brings synonyms or like things together into bigger and bigger sets where only one of the keywords HAS to be present. The boolean AND causes citations to appear on a list where both or all the terms must be present in each listed citation.

ADJACENCY and other forms of PHRASE searching will be more specific as the rules of such searches are more strict, i.e., a two or more word phrase must be in each citation. Not all Database Systems do phrase or adjacency searching.

From PubMed use:
Bring together keywords from the title and abstracts
  • unobtrusive 
  • stealthiness 
  • secretly 
  • concealed 
  • hidden 


Apply (combine/cross) to Animal Studies and not Human Studies. 

You may also ask for "Wild animals" which is a subject heading.

5. Perform the search and look at results. Precision needs to be balanced against the possibility of looking at false drops. It is better to do a broad search and get false drops than to try to be so precise that useful items are not retrieved. The NOT boolean operator should be used carefully, if at all. Get information from this search such as new keywords or assigned subject headings. If the search is not productive consider alternative approaches. One such approach is noted below in: "Continuing SEARCH STRATEGY"
6. Redo your search within formation from the previous search and with the new keywords.  In PubMed you have a feature called "Related Articles" which will automatically perform a search for you for similar types of citations.

 

Back to the Top 

Continuing search strategy
1. Adjust the question you are asking. The change here is to add how such studies are done, i.e., by marking the animals and observing and examining them. How can research on animals in the wild be done unobtrusively with various marking and capturing techniques?
2. Choose the databases related to your question and needs. The example here continues to use PubMed but the other databases will be tried, too, and the differing results should be noted.
3. List and organize keywords from your question. "Organization" of the keywords means how they will be used with the boolean operators AND and OR, and also with ADJACENCY operators, where available.
4. New keywords are used here and we continue to combine/cross sets of terms to focus on our question.
From PubMed use:
Bring together keywords from the title and abstracts
  • trapping 
  • capturing 
  • marking 
  • ear notching 
  • toe clipping 
  • identifying or identification 
Apply (combine/cross) to Animal Studies and not Human Studies. 

You may also ask for "Wild animals" which is a subject heading.

5. Perform the search and look at results. Get information from this search such as new keywords or assigned subject headings.
6. Redo your search with information from the previous search and with the new keywords.  In PubMed you have a feature called "Related Articles" which will automatically perform a search for you for similar types of citations.



 

Subject headings and keywords for searching

USE: "ethic*" and/or "alternative*" as necessary with the words listed below as well as "wild animal*" or "wildlife".
(the asterisk means: truncate parts of words to get all variations such as for ethic* you can get: ethic, ethics, ethical, ethically)
capture of animals unobtrusive or obtrusive identification, identifiers stress
trap or traps or trapping unintrusive or intrusive markers or marking pain
handling minimally invasive tags or tagged or tagging cruelty
field methods minimize* transponder or transponders

impact tracking

research banding


toe clipping


ear notching


implant or implants

 
Back to the Top




Search Templates:
AGRICOLA  This free version of the US National Agricultural Library database system includes references to articles and books from agriculture, including over 45 veterinary journals.

Here are some search templates for wild animals:

Capturing wild animals

Marking wild animals

Identification of wild animals

The free version of the PubMed Database, Pubmed is the US National Library of Medicine's database of journal articles. 

Trapping wild animals welfare
Live traps


Conclusion

Finding useful information about the ethical study of wild animals is difficult. The keywords which are used have multiple meanings and there is not a set of good authoritative subject headings available. Searches which are fairly general and broad in fact seem to produce the best results. The searches do not identify alternative methods or techniques, but do provide a set of citations which should include that information. When a search about ethics and trapping produces a set of about one hundred citations, it is often better to scan those citations yourself than to limit the results by adding another keyword.

We have demonstrated searching in various free systems so that any researcher could have easy access, but the free systems have limitations on how well they search. Commercial venders such as SilverPlatter allow flexible and precise searches of Agricola and CAB simultaneously, which can be very efficient.

In the final analysis, a good bibliography or specialized database directed at concerns for wild animals is necessary. Such a bibliography would be the result of reviewing many citations from many searches and would eliminate the many false drops. It would list only those which were actually related to the topics of research on wild animals with minimal impact on those animals. Creating a good bibliography or specialized database would be an excellent and worthwhile project.
 
Back to the Top



Kenneth Firestein
Carlson Health Sciences Library
Lynette A. Hart

UCDavis Center for Animal Alternatives Information
 

2/13/07


School of Vet Med Home UC Davis Home
What's New | About | Teaching | Students | VMTH | Research | Gifts | Cont Ed | iWeb | Search
SVM Home | UC Davis | Contacts