| |
|

MPAs
are one of many management or conservation tools that must be used in
conjunction with other strategies. The answer to the question "Do
MPAs work?" depends on the goal of the MPA. The goal of MPAs can
range from the protection of ecosystem biodiversity to enhancement of
a specific fishery or the protection of a particular species (e.g., red
sea urchins or northern bottlenosed whales). The merit of a specific MPA
or network of MPAs must be judged on the success to which it achieves
its set goal. In general, many fisheries reserves are designed to have
regional effects, whereas many biodiversity reserves focus on protecting
species within a defined area. Potential goals that have been suggested
for MPAs include:
 |
Enhancement
of local fisheries. Reduction of localized fishing pressure tends
to have a dramatic effect on the numbers and size of exploited fish.
Larval fish originating from elsewhere in the marine ecosystem are
thought to supply MPAs with fish. |
 |
Enhancement
of regional fisheries. The operative theory is that larvae produced
by mature fishes breeding within MPAs will disperse outside the MPA
and enhance local stocks. Few scientific studies have examined the
impact of an MPA on surrounding "fished" areas. |
 |
Local
enhancement or protection of species richness. The protection
afforded by MPAs often affect numerous complicated ecological processes
and the results on species richness can be variable. In some cases,
protection from physical disturbance like trawling or protection from
harvest can increase species richness. In other cases, the composition
of the community will be altered, but actual species richness will
not change. |
 |
Regional
enhancement of biodiversity. The objectives of the MPAs are to
be able to export local effects (larvae, invertebrates, fish, etc.)
into unprotected areas. More research is necessary to better understand
if this objective is realistic. |
While
there is general consensus that MPAs enhance biodiversity within their
boundaries, there is on-going debate as to their merits for enhancing
biodiversity and sustaining fisheries outside of their boundaries. Scientific
investigations of MPAs as fisheries management tools vary in their findings.
Examples of scientific literature concerning this debate can be found
at the federal MPA library reference list at http://mpa.gov/mpaservices/library/referencelist.html
|